Will medical political history repeat itself in 2024?

“The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again.” —The Eye of the World, Book I of the Wheel of Time Series of Novels.One of the advantages (?) of being old, is that you can see when history is about to repeat itself.Having followed medical politics for over three decades now (!), I continue to be amazed at how things keep circling, just like in the Wheel of Time series of novels. Unlike those books however, the Wheel in Medical Politics (WIMP?!?) would seem to come around every decade.Case in point is the current crisis in family practice.I won’t bore with you the details yet again since this issue is all over the news. But I will bore you by pointing out that this is currently the third major healthcare crisis in my career.In the late 1990s, there was a significant shortage of family physicians (sound familiar?). The shortage was made worse by poor payment for family physicians and poor working conditions. The Ontario Medical Association (OMA), which was supposed to represent all physicians, was widely viewed by the members at the time to be sorely lacking in helping family physicians. This led a few physicians (among them Drs. Sharla Lichtma/Rochelle Schwarts/Suzanne Strasberg) to form the Coalition of Family Physicians (COFP).Being politically savvy, they went out to the media and said things that the OMA, for whatever reason, did not.Not only did they get the attention of the press, they were (regardless of whatever revisionist history may suggest) instrumental in forcing the government of the day to institute Primary Care Reform and bring in the capitation models of funding for family practice. Their leaders also ran for OMA positions, with one of them, Dr. Suzanne Strasburg, eventually becoming the OMA president. It would be erroneous of me to suggest the OMA suddenly became an organization that had the undying love of its members, but the reality was that there was a noticeable shift in tone of their messaging when various members of the COFP got elected to the OMA Board.Fast forward to the mid 2010s, and, once again there was a (you guessed it) crisis in medicine. This time, the crisis was created by militant Health Minister Eric William Hoskins, who was hell bent on doing things his own way. It’s not without reason that one grumpy old coot coined the moniker “Unilateral Eric” for him. Hoskins and his belligerent Deputy Minister Bob Bell were so certain that what they were doing was right that they never bothered listening to the many intelligent people who tried to help them.Shockingly for most of us, instead of defending doctors, the OMA got into bed with Hoskins and Bell (aack! now I can’t get that image out of my head) and actually agreed on a tentative contract that stabbed doctors in the back.Once again, when the OMA couldn’t deliver for physicians, a breakaway group of doctors got organized on social media. They were led by a strong crew of doctors that included the likes of Drs. Nadia Alam, Paul Hacker, Silvy Mathew and advised by people like Dr. Paul Conte and too many others to name. Despite being weighed down by an ancient, crotchety bugger, they went and said and did things that the OMA couldn’t. They caught the eye of the media and the hope of the membership. Eventually, some of them (you guessed it) wound up on the OMA Board. Once again, while the OMA hardly became beloved by members, there was a noticeable shift in the tone from the OMA. Remember the ”Not a second longer” ads? And yes, Dr. Alam (and the guy who came in on her coat tails) both eventually wound up being president of the OMA.As we head into the mid-2020s (!), the Wheel of Time is turning, and the Age is now being reborn. Once again the crisis in Family Medicine is in the forefront. Once again, the OMA is seen by many to be lacking in defending the profession.N.B. I really do appreciate the work of most of the staff at the OMA, but the reality is that the OMA has spent much of the past couple of years pushing their “Prescription for Ontario.“ To be fair, it’s a very good document with many positive ideas for change. But the blunt reality is that no one in government asked for it, any similarity to what government is doing is purely co-incidental and not because they are listening to the OMA, and the unrelenting focus on it makes members feel as if you the organization is not advocating for their own personal wellbeing.And of course, we now have the Ontario Union of Family Physicians. A breakaway group that has gone out and said and done things the OMA can’t. Led by Drs. Ramsey Hijazi, Britt Harrison, Vakar Khan, Alex Duong and too man others to name, the group has, in very short order:set up an incredibly slick and well functioning websitebeen active in the media talking about why family physicians are quitting and not being afraid to mention that poor pay is (along with the admin burden) a root cause.Began a job action campaign that the OMA can’tAnd yes, one of their own, Dr. Ramsey Hijazi, is now running for OMA Board (along with Drs. Paul Conte and Paul Hacker). Full disclosure—I’m voting for all three of them, and you should too—and no, they didn’t know I would endorse them in this blog.It’s easy to get cynical about medical politics when one sees how things keep circling. Truth be told, I’ve had my own moments of pessimism where I’ve wondered why things don’t change permanently. But the reality is that any big organization will have a tendency towards inertia. That’s just life.But what’s also reality is that these organizations also significantly benefit from having people who are widely viewed as outsiders, or “disruptors” come in and shake things up. This is a healthy thing (whether the organizations thinks so or not). And it seems, in 2024, we may get that again.Dr. Sohail Gandhi is a former president of the OMA and opinions are his and not necessarily the opinions of the OMA board or of anyone at the Canadian Healthcare Network. This article is a reprint from his blog: justanoldcountrydoctor.com.

Will medical political history repeat itself in 2024?

Register for free access or login.

Related Topics