Dear Premier Ford, you know you’re a conservative, right?

Dear Premier Ford, I’m not exactly your harshest critic. I actually support some (not all) of what what you’ve done in healthcare. Moving procedures from hospitals to outpatient clinics, building new hospitals, enhanced funding for pediatric mental health, are good steps. I hope there will be more commendable steps in the future. However, I would be remiss if I didn’t point out that the healthcare system is going to be under a lot of fiscal pressure in the next couple of years. The remuneration that taxpayers pay for front line healthcare workers is about to increase drastically. You will note, I hope, that I said “taxpayers” pay. I, like you in the past, try to avoid saying “government money.” The money to pay for healthcare and other services comes from the pockets of the little guy as a certain politician once put it. Calling it “government money” is just a way to deflect the truth. At any rate, you are no doubt aware that the nurses in Ontario got a well deserved 11% arbitration award. You are probably aware that negotiations for a Physicians Services Agreement in Ontario are about to begin. Given that Manitoba just negotiated a record overall funding agreement with their doctors, and Nova Scotia doctors got a significant increase, you will not be able to hold the line against physicians getting an increase in Ontario. Which of course means that many more healthcare workers will want an increase too. In short, there is going to be a lot of fiscal pressure on the taxpayer in the near future. With that in mind, I will confess that my biggest disappointment in your management of healthcare is that I can’t honestly see that your government has reigned in the bureaucratic bloat that has so hampered the ability of front line physicians (and other healthcare workers) to look after patients properly. Bureaucratic bloat is common in all government agencies. I greatly admire politicians who’ve made comments about needing to “end the gravy train” that provides jobs for bureaucrats and a myriad of consultants at the provincial government. Perhaps it’s because I live it daily, but no where does this gravy train seem to be so prevalent as healthcare. Let’s look at digital health in Ontario for example. You have Ontario MD, which is an arms length agency that claims to be “the only truly provincial digital health network in Canada”, whatever that means. When I was on the OMA Board, OntarioMD was funded by taxpayers around $18 million a year. But wait, you also have eHealth Ontario, that claims to be “creating a secure electronic health record information system so that all your medical information can be safely shared and accessed by your healthcare providers." If I can decipher their audit statements correctly, they get a further $234 million dollars in revenue. But that’s not all. The ministry of health has not one but TWO separate departments that appear to deal with health IT issues. Their organizational chart clearly shows a bureaucrat in charge of Health Services for an Information and IT cluster. She has her own team of well-paid bureaucrats. Yet there is another bureaucrat in charge of Digital and Analytics strategy all with his own team of well-paid bureaucrats. The Digital Health Branch of the ministry of had a budget of almost $324 million in 2021-22. And this is where the waste comes in. You have three agencies (one with two departments) to deal with one field, all reporting separately, none of whom necessarily agree with the other on what to do next. I saw this a lot at government when I was with the OMA. So progress was significantly impaired in digital health because not only was there not one vision amongst the agencies, but because every single issue went back and forth between the three agencies to try to get alignment (to cover the asses of the Sunshine List bureaucrats in case something went wrong). As a result, we are far behind every developed country (except the United States) when it comes to digital health. I remember a politician who said: “What drives me crazy is when you have a supervisor in government, and they report into 12 other supervisors. That’s unacceptable.“ That’s exactly what happens with the digital healthcare strategy in Ontario. But moreover, the same thing happens in every single branch of the healthcare system. I mean seriously, if you already have a Clinical Care and Delivery branch of the ministry (see organizational chart) why do you need a separate arms length agency like Cancer Care Ontario? Or Ontario Drug Benefit? Or myriad others? They should be rolled up into the ministry. There are many more examples, but you get the point I hope. If you were to simply stop funding OntarioMD (which in my opinion is no longer useful) and the scandal-plagued eHealth Ontario (which completely failed in its mission anyway), that would represent a savings of $250 million. At $100,000 each, that could pay for 2,500 front-line nurses. Clearly nurses who provide front-line care are more needed than bureaucrats who go around in circles. The bureaucrats will no doubt fight you if you tried to do this. They will produce reams of power points and glossy manuals (all on the taxpayers dime, of course) saying their work is important. But seriously, what would you expect from those who are accustomed to the gravy train? Conservatives are supposed to be about reducing government waste, decreasing bureaucracy and efficient delivery of services. These are age old principles that, to be honest, I have yet to see from you as premier. If you don’t want to heed my advice, might I suggest that you instead take to heart the advice of the politician I mentioned above who wanted to end the gravy train and reduce the reporting to 12 other supervisors nonsense. That politician? A guy by the name of Doug Ford. Respectfully submitted, An Old Country Doctor. Dr. Sohail Gandhi is a former president of the OMA and opinions are his and not necessarily the opinions of the OMA Board. This article is a reprint from his blog: justanoldcountrydoctor.com.

Dear Premier Ford, you know you’re a conservative, right?

Register for free access or login.

Related Topics